Andmcit
January 13, 2008 12:47 am
Hi - just to add my tuppensworth to this interesting and varied thread with the current
emphasis on auto's!!
I've run both manual and auto Citroens for years from the Cx's through to Xantia and Xm's
and the worst of the lot for longevity and reliability are undoubtedly the Xantia/Xm auto's.
A ZF box on a 2.0i Xantia that's an almost identical design to the one in the Xm lost all it's
forward drive and I got a BRAND NEW off the pallet (from a Citroen agent closing down) one
fitted. After the graft of installing it I took the car for a drive and was crestfallen as it appeared
the car wasn't changing through the gears and seemed to like constantly accelerating hard in
a high* gear/high revs. It took a long while and a lot of convincing before I realised it was
changing gears but they were so superb/feathered and smooth I couldn't detect the changes.
I drive another similar miles/age Xantia that you certainly can feel the changes. (*1st/2nd)
Whilst this proves the changes can be smooth the change points very much need that critical
30 then 40 etc speed which onthecut correctly describes as being very irritating especially on
our Police State road system all technologied up to the gunwalls...
When auto's work OK they can be a joy to use especially in a grind commute but if you cross
country drive and enjoy rowing the car along in a spirited fashion through the gears an auto is
out of it's depth and can be hopeless when it comes to overtaking a slow vehicle etc. I don't
fancy banging a load of unnecessary high revs through the box just to get a bit of welly to
overtake.
I say stick to manuals - and I am biased = you don't have to be neurotic with one compared
to an AUTO and that really stands for diesels too - petrol any day for me!!
Which brings me to LPG!! I think it's the way forward as Diesel and it's dodgy alternative home
brews are ultimately doomed to cost the arm and the leg the way unleaded is going but there'd
be riots if home heating gas hiked up the costs scale in the scheme of things...
this can easily find it's way into the car's tank if you're handy with things...

Don't forget as well, if the installation is done properly and you use a donut tank under the floor
you keep the car's carrying capacity but also the existing fuel tank to actually INCREASE the
car's touring range not decrease it, hence preventing worries about finding the next tank
- actually there's loads of places when you start to actually look for something, it's easier to
see on a daily basis.
The worst compromise is the lack of a spare for that 1 in 10 times in your life puncture!
Most Alfa's and even Smarts new today don't come with a spare either and realistically how
often are most folk far away from home/family/friends back up should our rubbish roads
start racking up the puncture count!!
Andrew