Andmcit
December 25, 2007 01:20 pm
It's just as well we all like different things in Xm's or we'd all be fighting over the same
things on ebay!! This wasn't a thread to open up that old chestnut/running battle between
the North and the South or is it S1 or S2!?
But if you insist:
I can only go by personal experience and by far and away much prefer MY S1's over the
MY S2's. I hate the watered down centre console/central/dash and main bash binnacle of
the S2 and am not the biggest fan of airbags although have these on Xantiae, so this
particular gripe isn't a big deal. It does however bloat the appearance inside the car which
strays massively off course from the original concept made by the design team.
There are exceptions to every rule but as a designer I find that the first idea/creation into
reality from the mind's eye is by far and away the best/optimum choice and follow up
design(s) are usually simply variations on a theme. I'm not saying the final design of the Xm
was the optimum/initial idea and in fact from various books there's a chance it may have
been totally different but it was the one we we all offered new from Citroen and I quite like it!!
Historically the first is always better than the follow up/sequel, and if we just concentrate on
Citroens how about the GS>GSA, CX, BX, Xantia and I accept a tad more difficult to separate,
the frogeye to the shart Ds (I actually think it's a draw here) and don't try telling me new
versions of Golf or Pug Gti are better than the first...
Progress just means bigger/fatter/heavier and more complicated and out of the window
go subtleties like aesthetics!
Merry Christmas everyone!!
Andrew